Development Office
Director, Fundraising Strategy and Analytics
Position Overview
The Archdiocese of New York serves approximately 2.5 million Catholics across nearly 300 parishes in Manhattan, the Bronx, Staten Island, and seven counties north of New York City. Rooted in a long tradition of faith, service, and cultural diversity, the Archdiocese advances the mission of the Church through worship, Catholic education, formation, charitable outreach, and support for local parish communities. Its fundraising and charitable ministries include the Cardinal’s Annual Stewardship Appeal, Catholic Charities, the Inner-City Scholarship Fund, and parish-based initiatives. These efforts depend on strong donor relationships, disciplined stewardship of resources, and effective fundraising programs.
The Director, Fundraising Strategy & Analytics improves philanthropic performance through effective use of donor data, direct mail and digital fundraising, CRM systems, and prospect intelligence. The Director works as a close partner to fundraising leadership, turning data into practical decisions about whom to solicit, how much to ask, when to engage, and which channels are most effective.
The Director, Fundraising Strategy & Analytics helps strengthen annual giving performance, donor participation and retention, personalized ask strategies, acquisition and reactivation efforts, and the identification of leadership and major gift prospects. Success requires both hands-on understanding of direct response fundraising and the analytical judgment to recommend, test, measure, and improve solicitation approaches.
Working collaboratively with fundraising teams, Communications, Operations, and the Donor Database Center, the Director ensures that the organization’s CRM, reporting, and data capabilities support effective campaign execution and meaningful revenue growth. The position also serves as an embedded analytics partner across the Archdiocese’s development and philanthropic programs.
This position’s primary work location is 488 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10022.
About The Archdiocese of New York
Established by Pope Pius VII on April 8, 1808, the Diocese of New York originally encompassed the entire State of New York and seven counties in northeastern New Jersey. As the Catholic population grew, particularly in New York City, the diocese became an important center of Catholic life in the United States. On July 19, 1850, it was elevated to the Archdiocese of New York.
Today, the Archdiocese serves approximately 2.5 million Catholics across nearly 300 parishes in Manhattan, the Bronx, Staten Island, and seven counties north of New York City. Its diverse geography encompasses urban neighborhoods, suburban communities, and rural areas, reflecting the rich cultural and religious diversity of the region.
Throughout its history, the Archdiocese has been shaped by generations of immigrants who brought their languages, traditions, and faith to New York. In response, the Church established parishes, schools, healthcare ministries, and charitable programs to serve generations of Irish, German, Italian, Puerto Rican, Dominican, Mexican, Filipino, Polish, Haitian, Central American, and other Catholic communities.
From landmarks such as Saint Patrick’s Cathedral to one of the nation’s largest Catholic school systems and Catholic Charities, the Archdiocese has maintained a longstanding commitment to worship, education, and service. It also shares a deep relationship with New York’s emergency responders, including the FDNY, NYPD, Port Authority Police, and EMS, providing chaplaincy and pastoral support in times of crisis and tragedy.
The Archdiocese continues to evolve in response to the needs of the faithful through worship, Catholic education, healthcare, formation, and outreach to the poor and vulnerable. Initiatives including Care of God’s Creation, the Office of Cultural Diversity, and United in Faith support vibrant parish communities and strengthen the Church’s mission across New York City and the Hudson Valley.
Rooted in more than two centuries of faith, service, and cultural diversity, the Archdiocese of New York looks to the future with a continued commitment to accompanying the faithful and serving the communities entrusted to its care.
The Director reports to the Chief Advancement and Stewardship Officer. They will partner closely with the Chief Advancement and Stewardship; Executive Director of Parish Development; annual giving, leadership and major gifts, and communications teams; the development and fundraising teams of Catholic Charities and the Inner-City Scholarship Fund; and Central IT.
Core Responsibilities
Fundraising Strategy, Direct Mail, and Digital Giving
- Partner with fundraising leadership to develop data-informed strategies that increase annual giving revenue, donor participation, retention, and average gift size.
- Guide direct mail strategy, including audience selection, donor segmentation, mail-file preparation and suppression, personalization, ask arrays, contact frequency, and campaign testing.
- Analyze solicitation results by segment and channel, including response rate, average gift, net revenue, acquisition cost, cost per dollar raised, and return on investment.
- Advise on integrated mail, email, and online giving strategies and the donor journey across channels; coordinate with communications and campaign operations on execution.
- Design and assess controlled tests of ask amounts, timing, audience selection, messaging, and channel mix; turn findings into recommendations for subsequent appeals.
Donor Analytics, Ask Strategy, and Retention
- Build practical donor segments using recency, frequency, monetary value, giving history, engagement, and other appropriate indicators.
- Develop and evaluate donor-level suggested ask amounts and gift arrays, including strategies for renewal, upgrades, recurring giving, reactivation, and donor acquisition.
- Identify trends in year-over-year participation, attrition, donor movement, and lifetime value; recommend interventions grounded in evidence.
- Produce clear campaign forecasts, segment-level performance analyses, and prioritized action plans for fundraising leaders.
Leadership Gift Prospecting and Portfolio Development
- Use giving history, affinity indicators, wealth screening, prospect research, and propensity models to identify and prioritize potential leadership and major gift donors.
- Work with gift officers to qualify prospects, establish appropriate pathways from annual giving to personal cultivation, and inform portfolio assignments.
- Provide prospect profiles and actionable recommendations, including potential gift range, engagement approach, and next steps; track pipeline progression and results.
CRM Strategy, Data Quality, and Systems Partnership
- Serve as the fundraising business owner and strategic partner for CRM-related priorities, ensuring donor records, campaign codes, solicitation history, giving data, and reporting meet development needs.
- Partner with Operations and Central IT on data integration, system improvements, analytics requirements, data governance, and validation during technology changes.
- Improve constituent householding, segmentation, campaign tracking, data integrity, and secure handling of donor information.
- Assess opportunities for marketing automation, prospect screening, and analytics tools, ensuring technology investments support fundraising outcomes.
Performance Measurement, Communication, and Leadership
- Maintain an agreed framework of fundraising KPIs and dashboards covering revenue, donor counts, retention, upgrades, campaign performance, and prospect pipeline health.
- Translate technical findings into concise, persuasive recommendations and decision-ready reports for fundraising and executive leadership.
- Build staff confidence in the responsible use of donor data through consultation, training, shared definitions, and practical tools.
- Where assigned, supervise or coordinate analysts and external partners, establish priorities, and ensure quality, timeliness, and documentation.
Qualifications
Required
- Demonstrated success in direct response fundraising, annual giving, advancement analytics, or a closely related fundraising leadership role, including hands-on experience with direct mail programs.
- Proven ability to use donor data to shape segmentation, suggested ask amounts, retention and upgrade strategies, and fundraising campaign decisions.
- Working knowledge of nonprofit fundraising CRMs and how constituent, gift, campaign, appeal, and solicitation data are used in daily development operations.
- Experience evaluating direct mail and digital fundraising results and translating performance measures into specific improvements.
- Familiarity with prospect research, capacity indicators, wealth screening, and partnership with major or leadership gift officers.
- Strong analytical reasoning, spreadsheet and reporting proficiency, data quality discipline, and ability to communicate clearly with nontechnical stakeholders.
- Ability to influence cross-functional partners, establish priorities, and connect analytical work to revenue and relationship objectives.
- Appreciation for and commitment to the Archdiocese’s mission and an ability to work effectively in a Catholic, mission-driven environment.
- Bachelor’s degree or equivalent combination of relevant education and professional experience.
Preferred
- Experience supporting fundraising at scale in higher education, healthcare, large nonprofits, or religious organizations.
- Experience with Raiser’s Edge NXT or comparable advancement CRM platforms.
- SQL Version 2019 proficiency and experience with Power BI, Tableau, Looker, or similar analytics tools; familiarity with data warehouses or CRM integrations.
- Experience with marketing automation, email fundraising platforms, analytics-based testing, and prospect screening tools.
- Knowledge of predictive modeling, propensity scoring, and tools such as Python or R.
- Experience leading analysts or supporting an organization through a CRM or reporting platform transition.
Measure of Success
Success will be evaluated through the quality and adoption of recommendations and their measurable contribution to fundraising outcomes. Initial priorities are expected to include a reliable donor segmentation and ask framework; an actionable multichannel testing plan; improved visibility into donor retention and campaign economics; a prioritized leadership prospect pipeline; and CRM reporting that fundraising staff can use confidently. Specific revenue and performance targets will be established in partnership with leadership following review of baseline data.
Compensation range for this position is: $175,000 - $200,000 annually.
This position is considered exempt and not eligible for overtime.
Interested candidates should send a cover letter and resume to: